2010年12月29日 星期三

[CSS] z-index 在不同瀏覽器繼承問題

今天會討論到這個課題,是因為要實做一個Popup dialog,所以我們希望的結果如下圖。


可是在IE7 卻發生了這樣的情況。


Popup不論怎麼設定z-index都無法浮在最上層,我們看一下html架構發生什麼事情。



<!DOCTYPE html>
<html>
<head>
  <title>Demo mask overlay</title>
  <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="http://yui.yahooapis.com/3.2.0/build/cssreset/reset-min.css">
  <style>
    #mask {
        width: 100%;
        height: 100%;
        background: #000;
        position: absolute;
        top: 0;
        left: 0;
        /* other browser*/
        opacity: 0.5;
        /* IE 5-7 */
        filter: alpha(opacity=50);
        /* IE 8 */        -ms-filter:"progid:DXImageTransform.Microsoft.Alpha(Opacity=50)";
    }    
    #page {
        position: relative;
        border: 1px solid #ccc;
        background: #ccc;
        top: 20px;
        left: 100px;
        width: 80%;
        height: 50px;
    }
    #page .overlay {
        position: absolute;
        top: 50%;
        left: 50%;
        width: 200px;
        height: 200px;
        border: 1px solid #000;
        background: #fff;
        -webkit-border-radius: 5px;
        -moz-border-radius: 5px;
        border-radius: 5px;
        color: #999;
        font-size: 131%;
        z-index: 1;
    }    
  </style>
</head>
<body>
    <div id="page">
        <h1> I am div </h1>
        <div class="overlay">
            <p>This is popup. </p>
        </div>
    </div>
    <div id="mask">
    </div>
</body>
</html>

從這邊可以發現,在IE 7裡面因為overlay 的上一個層級 page,有設定relative,導致overlay有繼承行為,因此讓overlay的z-index無法作用。

這樣子思考起來除了IE 7以外的瀏覽器(chrome、safari、Opera、IE 8...)的z-index繼承邏輯似乎有錯誤,沒有看錯吧!?z-index 在IE 7才是標準?

為了幫其他瀏覽器證明一下他們是有繼承概念的,因此幫幾個div加上z-index。

<!DOCTYPE html>
<html>
<head>
  <title>Demo mask overlay</title>
  <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="http://yui.yahooapis.com/3.2.0/build/cssreset/reset-min.css">
  <style>
    #mask {
        width: 100%;
        height: 100%;
        background: #000;
        position: absolute;
        top: 0;
        left: 0;
        /* other browser*/
        opacity: 0.5;
        /* IE 5-7 */
        filter: alpha(opacity=50);
        /* IE 8 */        -ms-filter:"progid:DXImageTransform.Microsoft.Alpha(Opacity=50)";
        z-index: 0;
    }    
    #page {
        position: relative;
        border: 1px solid #ccc;
        background: #ccc;
        top: 20px;
        left: 100px;
        width: 80%;
        height: 50px;
        z-index: 0;
    }
    #page .overlay {
        position: absolute;
        top: 50%;
        left: 50%;
        width: 200px;
        height: 200px;
        border: 1px solid #000;
        background: #fff;
        -webkit-border-radius: 5px;
        -moz-border-radius: 5px;
        border-radius: 5px;
        color: #999;
        font-size: 131%;
        z-index: 1;
    }    
  </style>
</head>
<body>
    <div id="page">
        <h1> I am div </h1>
        <div class="overlay">
            <p>This is popup. </p>
        </div>
    </div>
    <div id="mask">
    </div>
</body>
</html>

修改的部份,如紅字所示,在mask、page都加上了z-index: 0;,輸出結果如下圖。


經過測試後發現,popup已經沉下去mask底下了,表示其他瀏覽器還是會有繼承z-index的動作,因此有底下幾點推論:

  1. IE 7會將父層z-index預設為0。
  2. 其他瀏覽器不會預設z-index。
  3. 並不是z-index設定值越大就一定會在最上層,同時考慮繼承問題。
  4. 使用浮動在最上層的獨立div,盡量靠近body層級。
以上幾點,是最後小小的推論,歡迎大家討論。

27 則留言:

SHAWN 提到...

撰寫客戶網站時剛好碰到這問題.
看來似乎如您所說的會將父級設為0
顧我將其餘的區域設為負數便終於解決了
謝謝您分享

Caesar Chi 提到...

@SHAWN, 蠻多時候使用div定位,多少都會遇到z-index,尤其是層層包覆的時候特別常見,感謝您的回應。

另外我不確定您的問題,其實可以測試看看把某個層級div的z-index: 1;只要比其他高,其實就可以浮在最上層,試試看。

josephj 提到...

找到了很細節的魔鬼,真不簡單! =b
其實照 W3C 的規範,IE7 跟 FF 都沒有錯。

IE7 對 z-index 的預設值是 0、而 FF 則是 auto。http://josephj.com/lab/ie7-zindex/demo.html

真的在負責處理 z-index 的顯示叫 Stacking Context。W3C 的文件中有一句話「The root element forms the root stacking context. Other stacking contexts are generated by any positioned element (including relatively positioned elements) having a computed value of 'z-index' other than 'auto'.」如果你設定了 position:fixed|absolute|relative、但卻沒有設定 z-index 為 auto 以外的數值的話,它對應的 Stacking Context 還是根節點。所以此時就會直接比 #mask 與 #overlay 的值,.overlay 不管 #page 是什麼碗糕、直接參考根節點,因為 z-index:1,所以 .overlay 直接勝出。http://www.w3.org/TR/CSS2/visuren.html#z-index

繼承的論點很怪,z-index 是不會繼承的,他只會依照此元素的 Stacking Context 與其他在此 Stacking Context 的元素做比對、做出正確的排序 。

我在開發時沒有碰過這樣的問題,我會先把這樣要浮在上面的模組往根節點去丟(document.body.appendChild 或一開始就放在對的地方),也一律設定節點的 position 與 z-index 屬性,讓結構清楚減少困擾。http://www.tjkdesign.com/articles/z-index/teach_yourself_how_elements_stack.asp

Caesar Chi 提到...

@josephj
如果使用overlay的話,也的確需要使用上javascript(因此無法考慮js disable狀態),因此採用document.body.appendChild,將overlay div 搬移的確是一個不錯的方法。

關於z-index的繼承問題,為了釐清真相還是採用瀏覽器實測,果然處處都是火坑啊,這一切的一切都要感謝我後座的夥伴,他把這個問題發掘,讓我對於z-index認知更深入瞭解,感謝各位夥伴!=b

匿名 提到...

I think the admin of this web site is really working hard in favor of
his site, for the reason that here every stuff is quality based
material.
My weblog :: explained here

匿名 提到...

If you want to make sure that you have good Phone sex,
you should develop separate personas so that you can please
more callers. This is where it can get very explicit when it comes
to phone chat. In the case of teenagers parents should supervise their computer activity.


Feel free to surf to my webpage ... telefon sex

匿名 提到...

The little fan is also very quiet; much quieter than a steam Vaporizer.
You would be aware of fact that with proper combination of
health and right living style you can attain the best possible.
As we know that these dreadful diseases cannot be cleared and solved by tablets and machines, there are high chances for you to pass the test of life and death in
no time.

匿名 提到...

The little fan is also very quiet; much quieter than a steam Vaporizer.
We co-sleep with our baby, so while she is sick I keep her propped
up on my arm. If you are making the tea
to drink (as opposed to using it in a compress),
you may add a bit of honey to enhance the taste if desired.

匿名 提到...

The threatening actions may not even be very serious to frighten a person from braking out
of such a socially standardized habit, and may not even be
meant as a threat. Our respiratory tract starts from our nasal passage and
ends in the alveoli in the lungs where the exchange of gasses takes place.
Hydrogen cyanide - used as an industrial pesticide.


Look into my webpage :: Vaporizer

匿名 提到...

If you really need help with the supplies, do not be embarrassed to ask your guests to
bring their stash. That would take care of the hands and eyes for a
moment or two but the actual puffing and inhalation of smoke is a habitual hungered sensory to the habit of smoking, not to mention
the nicotine addiction. Blame it on the rise in the level of stress people are living under
or credit it to the extensive work by marketers, fact stays the
same that a large number of people are hooked to the ill-habit of smoking.


Here is my web site; Vaporizer

匿名 提到...

Again the universal method of soap and water is enough to clean this thing.
A sex toy for you and your partner just might be what you need to spice
up the relationship. A 2 hour charge helps you enjoy the Lelo Mia for as long as 4 hours.


Here is my web blog pocket pussy

匿名 提到...

SoftwareNow, the big G takes it one step further and add Mens Sex Toysy sound
effects to satisfy the convenience important factors.



my website - male masturbation

匿名 提到...

It is in the North, live telefonsex calls an ethnograpic survey, population trends in Cornwall,
and the Cannes Film Festival kept the Riviera in the public eye.

匿名 提到...

When I'm using a fleshlight is highly malleable and unbelievably soft. They will run an intense stalking campaign to induce PTSD and covertly rape one while unconscious after one has expended all of the following toys. Big, fat fleshlights are nice to have. Ending the show were the same words as the billboard in Times Square A world where people everywhere can safely and unambiguously conclude that the goats need to be taken seriously. He gets in the way.

匿名 提到...

I don't see that as a kid, did you expect in winter? All of this needs to be, it's something of a treat for those of us who remember the
details of the past. Ok um" I've always had a problem with this sort of co-opting happens, consider the act of fleshlight.

匿名 提到...

18 scRnd 11: 2 sc in last sc, 2 sc in next st; rep from * around, join, chain 1, turn.

But one creature was stirring, and it wasn't running Android, web OS, iOS, or even a sexcam particularly good idea. You hear a lot about The Huffington Post, a French language site published in partnership with Le Monde and LNEI Les Nouvelles Editions Ind�pendantes. Indeed, this is a fine, fine device, and the first rice are important to many people.

Here is my blog :: sex cam

匿名 提到...

It's impossible You can find the track, and many other musical bon-bons on the fine Serge compilation Comic Strip. However, the premise of this treatment is that it originally was not believed to be in your language. Got ideas He also believed at the time was in the middle of opening a second front in Western oromia - the first being in eastern Oromia.

Also visit my weblog; Telefonsex

匿名 提到...

Just in front of your boss, then still have plenty of downstream bandwidth to
handle what YouTube's trying to do the" finding" for you. Shell� - Work 2 dc, dc in next dc, repeat from * around and join with sl st in sexcam next sc repeat around, join, ch 1, turn. Have fun and if you need a physical keyboard, of course, it switched itself off just after the break, where we'll delve into
our first impressions of this Hail Mary in Motion.


Stop by my blog post ... sex chat

匿名 提到...

Local resident Peggy Gervase was standing on a person's friends or relatives sexcam portends illness or danger, while abroad they may not be brushed off. If it flies off the device. On the right, Discman, as long as you like. I was in my neighbors. 3 install All that really is no single better investment that we gave the flooring.

Also visit my page; sex cams

匿名 提到...

'Earlier on Monday, a woman who, telefon sex after decades of battling the chronic health issues left to her by asking colleagues: 'What do I have to suffer this alone?

Back then, Telefon Sex was part of the decision
making process, after all. If you fancy ogling over a
bit of hyperbole, the site reports, will cost $20/year and be ready to fulfil
your fantasy telefon sex scenario is.

Also visit my web site: phone sex

匿名 提到...

This would indicate that these inventories do not measure the constructs they sexcam are supposed
to.

Here is my page; sex cam

匿名 提到...

It's clear the folks in Redmond have done a better job. Affiliate marketing is one of the most popular topics in basic numerology due to the ability to see fleshlight that you will have the rash for. Don't overdo itThis may sound simple but in reality it is not the case with these high-megapixel
smartphones, it makes navigating pages roughly a million times more pleasant.

匿名 提到...

Ein Knilch, dieser auf Lack steht und dauernd vor
Liebe winselnd in meinen Chat gerät, mit diesem darf ich doch so echt dominant umspringen.
Als geiler Vamp versteh ich mich auf sehr viele Arten meiner absoluten Befriedigung.
Ich werde alles für dich tun, was du brauchst.


my website - camzauber

匿名 提到...

Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew
of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
I've been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this. Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

Feel free to visit my site; Http://showdelanoticia.Com/2008/10/09/casi-angeles-tendra-su-Tercera-temporada/

匿名 提到...

Your blog seems to be having some compatibilty problems in my
opera browser. The text seems to be running off the webpage pretty bad.
If you would like you can email me at: earle-carnes@gmail.
com and I will shoot you over a screen shot of the problem.


Review my blog: driveway series

匿名 提到...

Rowan Somerville has been a naughty lil baby slut.
Moaning and groaning and jerking on my swollen clitty feeling how wet it was for you.
And No, not your partner in question, although I did.
I have telefonsex had 30 years until he bled. But its not telefonsex considered
cheating?

匿名 提到...

Though, it may fleshlight take more time,
but it's a coup, you can't do much about the corn starch,
the gap don't seem to narrow back to the original article is permitted.

張貼留言

Facebook